Crime and Courts

Cat Matlala Admits R500k Payment to Shadrack Sibiya

‘Cat’ Matlala Admits Handing R500,000 to Former Deputy Police Commissioner Shadrack Sibiya

Businessman Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala has admitted to handing R500,000 to former Deputy National Police Commissioner Lieutenant-General Shadrack Sibiya, during testimony before the Madlanga Commission of Inquiry in Pretoria. Cat Matlala Returns to Madlanga Commission Monday

The admission emerged on Tuesday, 10 November 2026, as the commission continued examining allegations of corruption, improper relationships and interference within the South African Police Service (SAPS).

Matlala told the commission that the cash was handed over in the basement of the State Theatre in Pretoria.

However, he maintained that the payment was intended as a contribution towards wedding expenses for a member of Sibiya’s family and was not a bribe.

His latest testimony marks a significant development in the inquiry, particularly because he had previously disputed allegations that he paid Sibiya R500,000.

Matlala Confirms R500,000 Cash Payment

During questioning, Matlala acknowledged giving Sibiya the half-million-rand payment.

According to Eyewitness News, Matlala said the handover occurred in the basement of the State Theatre.

He maintained that the money was intended to assist with wedding expenses for Sibiya’s son.

The admission followed extensive questioning about statements Matlala had previously made to investigators.

Evidence leaders have been examining whether payments allegedly made to senior police officials were connected to improper influence, protection from investigations or government contracts.

Matlala has disputed suggestions that the R500,000 payment was intended to secure favours.

His explanation has not been established as fact by the commission.

Another R50,000 Payment Acknowledged

Matlala also admitted giving Sibiya a separate R50,000.

He told the commission that the payment occurred during the SAPS Excellence Awards in KwaZulu-Natal.

However, he disputed an account suggesting that the money was handed over inside Sibiya’s office.

Matlala maintained that the two acknowledged payments totalled R550,000.

The commission has heard other allegations involving larger amounts, but Matlala has challenged several of those claims.

The distinction is important because his acknowledgement of specific cash payments does not amount to an admission that the money was paid as a bribe.

Investigators and the commission must still establish the circumstances and purpose of the transactions.

Matlala’s Testimony Changes After Earlier Denials

The latest admission follows contradictory testimony concerning the R500,000 payment.

During earlier questioning, Matlala disputed the contents of statements attributed to him and maintained that he had only given Sibiya R50,000.

On Tuesday, however, he acknowledged the larger payment while rejecting the suggestion that it was connected to corruption.

The commission questioned him about inconsistencies between his oral evidence and previously signed statements.

According to reports from the proceedings, Matlala disputed substantial portions of a witness statement prepared during discussions with investigators from the Investigating Directorate Against Corruption (IDAC).

He alleged that some information had been included without his approval.

Those allegations remain contested and have not been independently established.

Matlala Claims Investigators Pressured Him

Matlala has accused investigators of placing him under pressure during discussions connected to a proposed plea agreement.

He claimed that he signed documents without properly reviewing their contents.

He also alleged that certain statements implicating senior police officials were inserted by investigators.

During earlier testimony, Matlala said he had been receiving psychiatric medication when he made some of the statements now being examined.

He suggested that his condition affected his ability to understand or recall what had been recorded.

These explanations were challenged during questioning.

Commissioners pressed him to explain why he had signed and initialled documents if he disagreed with their contents.

The commission has not made a final determination on the accuracy of his allegations against investigators.

Failed Plea Agreement Under Scrutiny

The disputed statements are linked to negotiations involving Matlala and the Investigating Directorate Against Corruption.

Those discussions concerned a corruption case associated with a SAPS health services contract awarded to his company, Medicare24 Tshwane District.

The negotiations did not result in a final plea agreement.

Matlala’s legal representatives previously argued that material connected to the unsuccessful negotiations should not be used during the commission’s proceedings.

However, commission chairperson retired Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga rejected the argument that the relevant witness statement could not be considered by the inquiry.

The decision allowed evidence leaders to continue questioning Matlala about its contents.

The commission is examining the statements as part of its fact-finding process, not determining criminal guilt.

Questions Surround SAPS Health Services Tender

The payments have also attracted attention because of allegations surrounding a SAPS health services tender.

Matlala’s company, Medicare24, was awarded a contract reportedly valued at approximately R360 million.

The contract later became the subject of investigations and corruption allegations.

During Tuesday’s proceedings, Matlala denied that the R500,000 payment to Sibiya was intended to secure or influence the contract.

He maintained that the payment was related to wedding expenses.

Evidence presented before the commission has raised questions about relationships between businesspeople and senior police officials, including whether personal financial transactions were connected to official responsibilities.

However, the existence of a payment does not, on its own, establish that a corrupt transaction occurred.

The commission must consider the available evidence, including witness testimony, financial records and competing explanations.

Commissioners Challenge Matlala’s Evidence

Matlala’s responses during questioning drew criticism from members of the commission.

Commissioner Advocate Sesi Baloyi expressed frustration after Matlala repeatedly declined to answer certain questions.

Evidence leader Advocate Thabang Pooe questioned him about statements connected to the failed plea negotiations.

Matlala disputed several passages and, during parts of the proceedings, invoked his right against self-incrimination.

Commissioners questioned how the inquiry could establish the facts if he refused to address material contained in documents bearing his signature.

The exchanges highlighted the difficulty facing the commission as it attempts to reconcile conflicting versions of events.

Allegations Involving Sibiya Remain Contested

Sibiya’s name has featured prominently in testimony concerning alleged corruption and improper influence within SAPS.

Previous witnesses have made allegations about payments, gifts and relationships involving Matlala and senior police officials.

However, those claims have not all been independently verified.

Sibiya has previously acknowledged knowing Matlala while denying an improper relationship.

Matlala’s latest admission establishes that he told the commission he handed over R500,000, but it does not establish the purpose of the payment beyond his own account.

Any allegations of criminal wrongdoing must be assessed through the appropriate investigative and judicial processes.

Why the R500,000 Admission Matters

The admission is significant because it provides a direct acknowledgement of a substantial cash transaction between a businessman facing corruption allegations and a former senior police official.

The commission is investigating broader concerns about the integrity of policing institutions and allegations of criminal influence.

Financial dealings involving senior officials are therefore relevant to its examination of possible conflicts of interest and improper conduct.

However, the commission must distinguish between evidence of a financial transaction and proof of corruption.

The central questions include why the money was paid, whether any benefit was expected in return and whether the payment was connected to official decisions.

Matlala’s explanation is one part of the evidence that must be evaluated.

What Happens Next at the Madlanga Commission?

The commission continues examining testimony and documentary evidence concerning alleged corruption and interference in the criminal justice system.

Matlala’s evidence is expected to remain important as investigators and evidence leaders attempt to clarify the circumstances surrounding payments and relationships involving police officials.

Further scrutiny may focus on the disputed witness statements, financial transactions and the extent to which different accounts can be corroborated.

The inquiry’s eventual findings will depend on the evidence presented and the commission’s assessment of its reliability.

Conclusion

Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala’s admission that he handed R500,000 to former Deputy National Police Commissioner Shadrack Sibiya has added another significant development to the Madlanga Commission’s proceedings.

Matlala maintains that the money was a contribution towards wedding expenses and denies that it was paid as a bribe.

He has also acknowledged a separate R50,000 payment while disputing broader allegations concerning his dealings with police officials.

The commission continues examining inconsistencies between his testimony and earlier statements.

For now, the purpose of the payments and the allegations surrounding them remain matters under examination.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *