Crime and CourtsPolitics

Cat Matlala Claims Lawyer Influenced Sibiya Testimony

Matlala Alleges Former Lawyer Influenced His Parliamentary Testimony on Sibiya

JOHANNESBURG, 29 October 2026 — Controversial businessman Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala has made serious allegations against his former legal representative, advocate Bronwynne Forbay, claiming that his evidence before Parliament’s Ad Hoc Committee was influenced to protect suspended deputy national police commissioner Lieutenant-General Shadrack Sibiya. Cat Matlala Back Dock

The claims appear in a draft affidavit reported by The Star, in which Matlala alleges that Forbay communicated with Sibiya during breaks in the parliamentary proceedings and instructed him how to respond to certain questions.

Matlala also claims that he was pressured to conceal aspects of his relationship with Sibiya, including details of visits to the senior police officer’s residence.

Forbay has categorically rejected the allegations.

The reported affidavit is not, by itself, proof of wrongdoing by Forbay or Sibiya. Its contents have not been independently verified or established through a judicial finding.

Matlala Claims His Evidence Was Coerced

According to the draft affidavit, Matlala alleges that his former lawyer influenced the evidence he gave about his relationship with Sibiya.

He claims that during adjournments of Parliament’s Ad Hoc Committee, Forbay contacted Sibiya and discussed questions Matlala was expected to face.

Matlala alleges that the information was then used to direct his answers.

The businessman claims that these exchanges took place in his presence.

If independently substantiated, the allegations could raise questions about the integrity of the evidence presented to Parliament.

However, the existence of the allegations does not establish that any improper communication occurred.

Dispute Over Visits to Sibiya’s Home

One of the central allegations concerns Matlala’s previous statements about whether he visited Sibiya’s residence.

Matlala claims he was initially instructed to deny having visited the property.

He alleges that the account was later changed and that he was directed to say he had visited the residence only once to collect his wife.

According to Matlala, that explanation did not reflect what actually happened.

The dispute is significant because the parliamentary inquiry has been examining allegations concerning relationships between senior police officials and individuals implicated in criminal investigations.

Matlala’s relationship with Sibiya has been one of the matters attracting attention.

Nevertheless, the draft affidavit does not establish the correct account of the alleged visits or prove that his earlier testimony was deliberately manipulated.

Allegations of Threats Against His Family

Matlala also claims that he was warned about threats against his family if he disclosed the full extent of his dealings with Sibiya.

According to the reported affidavit, Matlala alleges that Forbay told him Sibiya had threatened to kill members of his family if he revealed certain information.

He further claims that his wife had warned him about threats before his parliamentary appearance.

These are serious allegations, but no independent evidence establishing that Sibiya made such threats was presented in the reporting reviewed.

The allegations must therefore be treated as disputed claims rather than established facts.

Any investigation would need to examine relevant communications, witness accounts and other supporting evidence.

Former Lawyer Rejects Allegations

Forbay has rejected Matlala’s accusations in strong terms.

In a response reported by The Star, the former legal representative described the allegations as false and unfounded.

Forbay maintained that the preparation of Matlala’s statement was undertaken in conjunction with the parliamentary evidence leaders.

The response also emphasised the professional obligations of confidentiality and legal privilege that apply to communications between lawyers and clients.

Forbay indicated that these obligations limit what can be disclosed publicly about the previous attorney-client relationship.

However, the former legal representative made clear that maintaining confidentiality should not be interpreted as accepting Matlala’s accusations.

This denial is an important part of the dispute.

At present, the competing accounts have not been resolved through an independent legal process.

Matlala Questions Lawyer’s Appointment

The businessman further alleges that Sibiya played a role in Forbay becoming his legal representative.

He claims that he eventually terminated the appointment because he believed Forbay was protecting Sibiya’s interests.

Matlala says he subsequently appointed Hlawu Maluleke Attorneys.

These assertions form part of his account of events and should not be interpreted as proof that his former lawyer acted improperly.

Determining whether a conflict of interest existed would require evidence beyond Matlala’s allegations.

Missing Cellphones Feature in Affidavit

The draft affidavit also contains allegations concerning two mobile phones reportedly seized during Matlala’s arrest.

The devices are described as an iPhone 16 Pro Max and an iPhone 15.

Matlala claims that although the devices were returned by police, they remained in Forbay’s possession after the legal relationship ended.

He further alleges that he was later informed that one of the phones had been stolen from a briefcase at the Krugersdorp Magistrate’s Court.

The reporting does not independently establish whether the alleged theft occurred, who had possession of the devices at the relevant times or whether they contained material relevant to the parliamentary proceedings.

The claims nevertheless introduce another disputed issue concerning Matlala’s communications and legal representation.

Parliamentary Inquiry Into Police Corruption

Parliament’s Ad Hoc Committee was established to investigate allegations of corruption, criminal infiltration and political interference within South Africa’s law enforcement institutions.

Its work followed explosive allegations made in July 2025 by KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner Lieutenant-General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi.

The allegations prompted extensive scrutiny of senior police officials, politically connected individuals and relationships between private business interests and law enforcement.

Matlala’s evidence has formed part of the committee’s broader examination of these matters.

Sibiya has also featured prominently in proceedings examining alleged interference and relationships involving police officials.

The allegations against him remain subject to the relevant investigative and legal processes.

Could Parliament Revisit Matlala’s Evidence?

The latest claims raise questions about the reliability of portions of Matlala’s earlier testimony.

If the allegations are formally presented to the committee, members may need to consider whether further clarification or supporting evidence is required.

Relevant issues could include whether communications occurred during adjournments, whether anyone had advance knowledge of questions and whether Matlala’s answers accurately reflected his own knowledge.

However, no verified finding currently establishes that parliamentary questions were improperly disclosed.

Matlala’s suggestion that Sibiya may have been communicating with committee members remains speculation unless supported by evidence.

The committee’s published records provide an official reference point for Matlala’s previous evidence and the broader inquiry.

Investigating Directorate Declines to Comment

The Investigating Directorate Against Corruption has declined to comment on the leaked documents.

Its spokesperson, Henry Mamothame, indicated that the directorate does not comment on leaked material or subjects of ongoing investigations.

He also confirmed that a proposed plea-and-sentence agreement involving Matlala became null and void after Matlala withdrew from the arrangement.

The abandoned agreement has featured in reporting about Matlala’s possible cooperation with prosecutors.

Its collapse does not establish the truth or falsity of the allegations contained in the draft affidavit.

Any criminal or disciplinary consequences would depend on properly investigated evidence and applicable legal procedures.

Madlanga Commission Context

Matlala has also appeared before the Madlanga Commission of Inquiry, which is examining allegations of corruption and interference in the criminal justice system.

During earlier commission proceedings, questions were raised about his relationships with senior police officers and allegations involving payments and government contracts.

The commission and Parliament’s Ad Hoc Committee are separate processes, although they examine overlapping issues.

Statements made in one forum should not automatically be treated as findings in another.

This distinction is especially important where witnesses change their accounts or make allegations about other participants.

What Happens Next?

The immediate question is whether Matlala’s new allegations will be independently investigated or formally placed before the parliamentary committee.

Investigators would need to examine the original affidavit, relevant communications and any available corroborating evidence.

Forbay’s denial would also have to be considered.

Sibiya’s response to the specific new allegations was not included in the principal report reviewed.

Until the relevant facts are established, claims of witness coaching, threats and improper influence remain allegations.

Matlala’s latest account has introduced a new dispute over the reliability of his parliamentary testimony, but it has not established that his former lawyer or Sibiya interfered with the inquiry.

The development adds another layer to the ongoing scrutiny of alleged corruption and influence within South Africa’s criminal justice system.

Ubuntu9Media will continue following developments involving Matlala, Sibiya, Parliament’s Ad Hoc Committee and the Madlanga Commission.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *